I prefer traditional Neopolitan pie that folds down when you pick it up, I never use a knife and fork. A little burnt but still soft, so the oil drips down !
Favorite topping- Crumbled Sausage ! Especially homemade.
1. Lombardi's, Spring St ,NYC Since 1905, now a tourist destination
Been there about 10 times, always excellent ! Coal Fired Brick oven
2. Pepe's New Haven and about 6 other locations, nice "chewy" crust
3. Louis & Ernies, Throgs Neck area, The Bronx. Best Sausage Pie ever!
4. Catania's Tanglewood Shopping Ctr, Yonkers NY Mini Calzones awesome!
5. Modern, New Haven. Best sausage pie EVER!
6. Primo Cucina, New Smyrna Beach, 1 of the best in FL
7. Zeneli, Wooster St, New Haven, Artisan pie
In no particular order
Baci, New Smyrna Beach FL
Moto Pizza E Falmouth, new and excellent. Slices and gifts!
Sal's Mamaroneck NY, Reg and Sicilian slices both great
John's Bleeker St also Chapel near Times Square NYC
Tutta Rosa St Pete Beach, FL
Juliana's Near B'klyn Bridge . east end Patsy Grimaldi owned
Goodman's American Pie, Ludlow VT Artisan
Pizzeria Bianco Phonix AZ , Artisan pie, great bread also
Pizza Time St Augustine Florida Slices!
Valentino's Sears Mall Tville FL
Mama Rosa's T'ville FL
Sally's in New Haven
Arturo's Houston St, NYC
Regina's North End Boston and several other locations
Santarpios Boston & Peobody MA Try the skewers!
Simply D'Vine Falmouth MA Artisan style
Pizza Barbone Hyannis MA Artisan style, Grows herbs & veggies on roof
Max & Leo's Newton MA Artisan
DiFaro's Brooklyn NY, I've never been but rated the Best!
Roma's Tuckahoe NY Super Thin
Primanti Brothers S Florida and Pittsburg & sandwiches
Pizza Restico around Miami, large square slices Lots of toppings
Joe's 6th Ave Greenwich Village NYC, Slices
Reste, Official Neopolitan, Artisan style, Bleeker St NYC
Bizzaro's, Central Florida Coast
Tiano's, New Smyrna Beach, FL, full menu
Valentino's, Sears Mall, Tville FL
Star Tavern Orange NJ , Bar pie, pizza quiz on their site
Johnny's, Mt Vernon NY
Grandma & Sicilian also love
Chicago Style Good but I prefer thin.
Some of the Rays Original Rays in NYC, heavy but usually good
I also make my own, I buy pre-made dough.
I know I missed some, the search continues, somebody's got to do it !
Suggestions welcome, no chains please !